I haven't updated this in a while but I can confirm that it's leaking out of the head gasket. You can see the oil all over the back, coating s---.. but it stops where the gasket is at, and the head is completely clean.
I decided also not to risk it... I didn't want to slap a new head on and find out that it wasn't the gasket but the head bolts, so I got some ARP head studs.
Since it's so cold out, a friend of mine I used to work for is going to do the job for me. He has an indoor garage and I do NOT feel like working on this car in the snow.
Going to call him either today or tomrrow. He has to get this old CJ Jeep out first before mine will go in.